Reave
[13] Hero
No. M$ fully intended to take a hit in sales. The M$ fanboys couldn't let the changes go and kept spreading misinformation which probably made M$ bottom line look worse off then they expected. If people simply spoke with their wallets instead of their keyboards we wouldn't have missed out on this awesome ass feature.Thank the dismal preorders you mean. I can't believe that logically the publishers were cool with MS giving away 9 copies of their games for free.
Also 1 copy between ten people is better than 1 copy between hundreds. I think you grossly underestimate how much a single used game can cycle through people. I guess publishers followed the concept of give a little to get a lot. Realistically, I doubt a lot of people even lend their game to 9 other people so they were really giving a whole lot.