Viola is Amy (CAS Inside)

It sure got you to type way more than you needed to. Don't you have more bets to be backing out of?

Soul Cancer.

Does anyone notice what Raphael says to Viola when they are battling together.
'You vex me. Who are you, woman?'
(Also note that Raphael is searching for Amy)
He also says 'This cannot be'

How about just no.

Her identity is Viola. Not Viola Amy or Amy Viola, she is her own self. That being Viola.

Whoa, whoa, whoa! Who said prostitute? I will have you know Viola is a powerful fortune teller and would never dabble in the flesh trade. Besides, her and I have been in a serious relationship for some years now.

wow... Keep your fantasies to yourself.

As for the Amy/Viola debate, even though i believe Viola is Amy for many points, i do think there's a argument to say that she's not.

In SC4 it is written that Raphael infected Amy and that she is no longer human. In SC5 Raphael's curse is called Vampire and he hasn't aged. That means if he turned Amy she can't be Viola because Viola is a grown woman with magic powers, not a child vampire.
With all reasons to believe Viola IS Amy, this is one good reason to think maybe she is not.

What maths are people doing to surmise that Amy should be 24 now, or was in IV?

Also:

• Daishi said a character would be returning with a new fighting style - Aeon. Kilik.
• The whole amnesia thing makes sense - Speculation, not proof.
• The flower motif and gothic lolita thing coincides perfect with each other from SCIV's Amy to SCV Viola - Fashion.
• Same color pattern; navy blue, purple ish, pink-rose-ish - See above. Also Ivy.
• Same Voice Actor!!!! Lmao - Only actual thing close to 'proof'.

Not that I could give a flying fox either way. Stop crying about it and play the game.

...the math of Tri-color star signs. Not years.

...also your list and how your wrote it doesnt sound like someone who doesnt care. More like someone who cant admit that there more better reasons to believe that she is Amy then that she isnt. Nobody here ever talked of proof only that the whole design/character of Viola is so much like Amy that it makes it very possible that she IS Amy.

SC4 says Raph infected Amy with edge curse so Amy is a vampire. - SC3 shows Kilik cure Amy from the curse in one ending. So it IS possible Amy was 'cured'. SC4 also only makes Raph bite people. Amy never bites anyone and she doesnt act in like a vampire in any way. Only the pale skin and red eyes that Viola also has.
Viola is 24 so she cant be Amy. - Viola is 24 Tri-color star signs. Her bio says nothing of her age in years.
The game doesn't say she's Amy so she isn't. - The game also doesn't say Patroklos wants to do the boogie woogie with his sister, but we all know better...

and before anyone else wants to go on a "i dont care but NO SHE ISN'T!!!!!!1!! lmao lol! im so cool" type reply:

I dont say there is proof that Viola is Amy. There is no proof for a yes or a no. Just more reasons to believe that she is then that she is not Amy.

Also as for the 'Daishi said...' argument. Daishi said so many things when they made SC5.

This subject is tiresome. I don't think this forum should be infected with all of this speculatory venom. Until Namco says otherwise, don't read into it

It seems to me that Namico is the real problem here -__-

I like how some guy necroes one thread and the result is two necroed threads, both with contentious topics.

Well then that's stupid because she was 17 in IV and would either continue being 17, or would have become 32.

Anyway, you're mistaken. I could not give a flying, streamlined toss either way. My post against that list from page 1 merely points out why none of it is 'proof' in any way. Whether she is, or isn't Amy, is inconsequential because she's acting, and therefore for all intents and purposes IS a different character.

Let's not get into any spiteful arguments anyone...

I personally think that Viola is Amy. ? = ?

-Her outfit is uncannily similar to Amy's
-Her hair bares a resemblence as well
-Ballet dancing moves
-The special quotes with Raphael
-Same voice actor

I however, won't downright tell everyone to throw out their opinion to belive in mine, that is a bit much. Everyone just needs to ease up, and know that everyone is entitled to an opinion.

And PS- Even if Viola isn't Amy, the game developers definately wanted us to think she is...

Since everyone and their mother has already thrown themselves to the bonfire I am just going to join the crowd and enjoy the burning flesh... from a top the cliff you all jumped off of. Please, try to be civil.

In my opinion, Viola is Amy. If I remember correctly, Sectus overlayed Amy and Viola's models and they are were an exact match, not similar, but an exact match. If that is so, that already greatly hurts a lot of naysayer's argument with hard evidence they are extremely similar. While of course, that proves nothing, as speculation will say (Amy's lost sister? We are going there now?), but a lot of speculation for the argument compounds together and really should get the gears turning, can there really be all these coincident? Then again, perhaps there can, and the rest of us are fools.

Let the fun begin:

--Forgon

No one can prove she is, and I can't prove she isn't. Basically no one knows shit.