Solo
[14] Master
From competitive players from the time I hear good and bad about SCII, more bad though. Casuals praise it either because they like a character from SCII, nostalgia goggles, or the 1P modes.As for the community being small I'm not sure about SC2 since I hear a lot of good things about it. All I know is that after SC2 the series started going downhill.
My opinion of SCII (based around the game engine itself, not the balance of the game, and my casual opinion.)
Game engine: I like that verticals barely have tracking at all, I hate stepG, retarded frame traps everywhere, extremely fast placed(a bit too much), wall splats are strange.
Casual stuff: the 1P modes are meh/gimmicky, bad voice acting, good character designs, interesting stages, good music, the museum is mildly interesting.
Other notes: The training mode sucks!