What's happening Dope!?
In terms of Soul Calibur in Indiana, I know there's not many people there playing. My buddy MysticBill used to live in Carmel, but has moved out of state, so no longer lives there. I know there's some peeps in Bloomington, Indiana that kind of play Soul Calibur still, & some of the peeps in my scene in Cincinnati/Dayton, Ohio, as well as Northern Kentucky still kind of play as well.
I would say besides Chicago, those places would be the best bet to go towards for offline Soul Calibur gaming. Indianapolis & Bloomington both have growing fighting game scenes there, so the best bet would be to hit up those guys to see if people would be down to play. I know Indianapolis has the Godlike Saturday series going on every month, & a lot of those peeps in both those communities go on Facebook a lot, so that may help you out as well.
If you have any other questions, definitely post back up for sure. Take it easy, welcome to Indiana/Midwest, & hope this helps you going forward.