What is the Best joystick for guard impact ?

Char9999

[01] Neophyte
I am a pad player been playing sc since sc2 . Recently i got hori sc6 Hayabusa . I have been practicing for 2 months and i can do all the moves consistently except guard impact . I think because it has long engage distance . What joystick do you recommend ?
 

Cookweave

[01] Neophyte
I initially ran on the Hayabusa stick, and the thing felt smooth, but it was too loose and had far too large a throw for me. The best option if you want to start off cheap is to buy a different spring tension and actuator. This will cost you only about 20% of the price of a JLF, and you may be able to customise the stick to your liking
 

Char9999

[01] Neophyte
I initially ran on the Hayabusa stick, and the thing felt smooth, but it was too loose and had far too large a throw for me. The best option if you want to start off cheap is to buy a different spring tension and actuator. This will cost you only about 20% of the price of a JLF, and you may be able to customise the stick to your liking
It cost about the same for me because of the international shipping . I am from saudi arabia . Does the jlf has a shorter engage distance than the Hayabusa ?
 

Cookweave

[01] Neophyte
I'm not sure if it actually does, but it certainly feels like it to me. Personally I prefer the longer throw, but the biggest killer for me was the fact the spring was too loose. I personally use a Crown 309FJ because I wanted the extra resistance, and I can GI fine on that as well. The sanwa stick will feel a lot more familiar to you, so unless you want to just buy both and experiment, I'd recommend getting the JLF
 

Char9999

[01] Neophyte
I'm not sure if it actually does, but it certainly feels like it to me. Personally I prefer the longer throw, but the biggest killer for me was the fact the spring was too loose. I personally use a Crown 309FJ because I wanted the extra resistance, and I can GI fine on that as well. The sanwa stick will feel a lot more familiar to you, so unless you want to just buy both and experiment, I'd recommend getting the JLF
I will get the jlf first because it is available to me without the international shipping . And later i may get the 309 mj . Thank you for answering my questions