Trying to Redeem the SCV Newcomers

HydroJames

Shining Sea Dragon
Hello, SC fans. In this thread we will discuss the characters SCV introduced and how can we fans to warm up to them.

It seems that the situation looks pretty bleak for them as they weren't well received and placed terribly low on popular polls. They were all victims of the circumstances that was SCV's rushed development as a result of a tsunami that hit Japan. However, I feel that there is still hope for them. How am I convinced? I was looking up Natsu's performance in Project X Zone 2 for the 3DS. Surprisingly, she was meet with warm reception as she was an entertaining character and had good chemistry with other characters. See what happens when you take the time to give them some character? It's no wonder why some people preferred Nastu over her master, Taki, who to some had little character beyond being "Ms. Sexy-Stotic-Ninja-Badass."

So, after hearing about this, I am motivated to look into how we make the other characters more likable.

Patroklos

He may well be the hardest character to get the fans to warm up to. While none of the new characters got the we're very liked by many of the fans, Patroklos attracted the most vile out of all of them. He was seen as a lame excuse of a hero who remorselessly kills innocent people for no reason. However, he wasn't supposed to be seen that way. Similar to Siegfried, he was supposed to start out as jerk before realizing the error of his ways and righting his wrongs. People who accuse him of being a remorseless killer will overlook the scene in SCV's story mode when he encounters his former employer, Graf Dumas, and finds out that he is Nightmare and the people he was sent to kill were not malfested, but innocent people which causes Pat to have a breakdown once he realized what he has been doing.

Also, I feel that people who look down on Pat and talk about what a great hero Siegfried was would ignore that Siegfried in his youth had committed atrocities that were just as awful, if not worse, than the ones Pat commited. Sieg's crimes include:
  • Falling into a bad crowd, joining a band of thieves.
  • Betraying and killing Sir Stefan, a comrade in the mist of the siege on the Ostrheinsburg castle for his sword, Grimblade, thinking it was Sour Edge.
  • Accidentally killing his father while ambushing his army. (His father was a commander of the German army. He should have known better.)
...and this was all before he found Soul Edge and became possessed by it. So, I feel if Siegfried can be redeemed and recognized as a great hero after he did all of this, then the same can be done for Pat. I feel a good place to start would be to expand on his A. Pat personality and have him realize that the malfested are human being under a terrible curse and they need help, just like he did for sister. That way, he could atone for his actions under Dumas.

Pyrrha

People like to give flack for her whiny behavior in SCV. If you look her backstory, you would learn that this is due to being a victim of circumstances beyond her control in the universe of the story. She was abducted from her family when she was too young to remember them and wound up being taken under the care of other people who would end mysteriously dying with her being blamed for it. It was all part of Tira's plot to manipulate her into becoming the host for Soul Edge. By the end of the story, she learns to stop being a victim and stop accepting everything around her as her fate. It would be interesting to see her grow a spine and stand up to Tira.

Xiba

It's pretty tough to figure out what to do with his character for me. From what I can gather, he is to Kilik what Nastu is to Taki. He was meant to be a fun take on a very serious character archetype. He was criticized for being idiot who spoke of nothing but food. However, there are people who like him, some even more than Kilik, due to finding his personality entertaining. I feel that perhaps he could be given the PXZ 2 Natsu treatment and have a fleshed out character, more material to work with, and have better chemistry with other characters.

Leixia

I have weird feelings towards her. I have desires to flesh her out like the other characters, but how is the challenge. Since people complained that she was too darn similar to Xianghua, I seek of a way to make her an interesting foil to her mother.

Z.W.E.I.

Believe it or not, he is actually one of the better received of the SCV newcomers. He was praised for having a unique fighting style, being quite a badass, and beating up Patroklos in the Story Mode... twice ("zwei" is German for "two", so it's kind of fitting). However, some dislike him for not having much in terms of personality, having a terrible aesthetic design, and having a very out the ordinary fighting style. His fighting is a cross shaped sword with three handles and wolf, named "E.I.N." that is summon from portals. Casual players have complained about how gimmicky, cheap, and out of place it is (some complaints are about he is too magical... for a series that is already loaded with fantasy elements, but that's another conversation for another thread). Competitive players also give him flack for being the arguably the worst character in the game in terms of tourney success, match-ups against other characters, and general effectiveness. Whenever they made a tier-list, they would generally agree that even the series' resident joke character, Dampierre, had him outclassed.

So, what I would do is not only expand on his character, but I would also improve on his fighting style so that wouldn't be bottom-tier garbage while not being game-breaking.


Viola

Most of what I said about Z.W.E.I. can be said said about Viola. One of the few key differencs is that her Orb-based fighting style made her the best character in the game. She might need a few nerfs.
 
I'm thinking exactly the same about Patroklos, I generally despise the hypocrisy that is going on on his case simply because some people put SC1 and SC2 above everything else to the point that they won't acknowledge Siegfried actually started the same as him, or even worse.

As for Pyrrah, she also grew up and the way she managed to handled Soul Edge to save her brother was badass.

But since we all know SCV was rushed, I'm just waiting for the next time they will appear to see if they're really worth it.
 
Like I said in another topic: Patroklos, Pyrrha and all newcomers from SCV were victims of the circumstances of the game. They were added because their gameplay was finished, but their story was not, so they ended up getting a rushed crap that made us hate or not care about most of them.
 
Well, I don't actually hate any new SCV characters except Pat. But I still enjoy Pat's movesets for my CaS characters. Also, I actually like Pyrrha, because I like the personality, but obviously, sometimes her sorry game is a bit too much. Also, having a character that doesn't want to fight and is scared... In a fighting game? What? ZWEI I quite like, he's pretty cool. I also like that he's connected to Sieg. Leixia is sweet, Viola is meh. Also, all the replacement characters are not good enough, rather obviously. But I only hate Pat. ...Cause he's Pat....
 
Viola is an excellent character, she has a lot of potential, as well as a very original moveset. Not to mention the likely connection to a fan favourite.
 
Hello, SC fans. In this thread we will discuss the characters SCV introduced and how can we fans to warm up to them.

It seems that the situation looks pretty bleak for them as they weren't well received and placed terribly low on popular polls. They were all victims of the circumstances that was SCV's rushed development as a result of a tsunami that hit Japan. However, I feel that there is still hope for them. How am I convinced? I was looking up Natsu's performance in Project X Zone 2 for the 3DS. Surprisingly, she was meet with warm reception as she was an entertaining character and had good chemistry with other characters. See what happens when you take the time to give them some character? It's no wonder why some people preferred Nastu over her master, Taki, who to some had little character beyond being "Ms. Sexy-Stotic-Ninja-Badass."
And yet Taki still got over 7x the amount over Natsu in the poll and utterly annihilated her in tournament. What's your point exactly?
 
Yeah, I barely see anyone that likes Natsu more than Taki, sure, Natsu has a much better-constructed personality, but nothing else, her backstory is not that impressive and got deleted, so we have really nothing but appearence and personality from her.
 
Yeah, I barely see anyone that likes Natsu more than Taki, sure, Natsu has a much better-constructed personality, but nothing else, her backstory is not that impressive and got deleted, so we have really nothing but appearence and personality from her.
I don't even know what you mean by that. Her whole "personality" was just a rip-off straight from Naruto. Taki had a way better personality on the account that she didn't annoy the shit out of you. Not to mention she's done far more heroic things than she did. The only thing I take away from Natsu is "Har har! I'm an annoying Naruto rip-off with stupid hair!".
 
I don't care about Naruto, but don't try to defend Taki's personality, ok? Because her personality can be seen in ten thousands of characters, its generic and extremely boring, while Natsu, despite being arrogant, at the very least is different, specially from what you usually expect from a ninja.
 
I don't care about Naruto, but don't try to defend Taki's personality, ok? Because her personality can be seen in ten thousands of characters, its generic and extremely boring, while Natsu, despite being arrogant, at the very least is different, specially from what you usually expect from a ninja.
It works. Taki is a stone cold badass, while Natsu is just an annoying little twerp.
 
It works. Taki is a stone cold badass, while Natsu is just an annoying little twerp.

Yep, Taki is a badass, while Natsu is a Naruto wannabee. At the end of the day, Setsuka makes all character's moves no longer matter.
 
There are other characters that are "badass" while still having some kind of character development. Sophitia, for example. Or Siegfried. But Taki, like Mitsu, is just kinda... there. Doesn't really develop as a character or contribute to the story.
 
There are other characters that are "badass" while still having some kind of character development. Sophitia, for example. Or Siegfried. But Taki, like Mitsu, is just kinda... there. Doesn't really develop as a character or contribute to the story.
Are you for real? She's done a lot more than Natsu, that's for damn sure.
 
Are you for real? She's done a lot more than Natsu, that's for damn sure.
It doesn't matter, her personality is still generic and boring in comparison to Natsu. And I don't know what you're making a fuss about, I said that Natsu's personality is the only thing she has going for her, you're already trying to bring stuff I didn't even mention. Taki's personality is garbage, end of story, there is nothing you can bring to defend that.
 
It doesn't matter, her personality is still generic and boring in comparison to Natsu. And I don't know what you're making a fuss about, I said that Natsu's personality is the only thing she has going for her, you're already trying to bring stuff I didn't even mention. Taki's personality is garbage, end of story, there is nothing you can bring to defend that.
No, it isn't. Taki's personality represents a strong, stoic, no-nonsense shinobi who values duty over all else. Natsu's personality reads word-for-word with Naruto. Natsu has literally nothing going for her. Now why don't we end this here.
 
Taki's personality is random and repetitive, that is what makes it awful, much like it makes lots of other characters in the series and other old characters from fighting games (see Street Fighter, half of the roster has no personality). Too bad for you that you are too blind to see that your perfect character is not that perfect, but there is a flaw on her that Natsu covers much better.
 
Explain to me how ripping off an anime character equates to "having a better personality"?
 
Explain to me how ripping off an anime character equates to "having a better personality"?
Explain YOU what exactly makes her so similar to Naruto. And explain why you say Natsu's personality is bad due to a ripoff that exists only in your head, while Taki rips off multiple various characters (who are ripoffs on their own) with her generic personality and I don't see you complaining about it.
 
Back
Top Bottom