MLG Winter Championships Review by Alex Strife

AlexStrife

Apex 2013 is here REGISTER EVERYONE!
It has been a very interesting weekend for the fighting game community. We had the great honor of having two amazing events on the same weekend. This, however, is not about both those events but the event everyone was looking to with untrusting eyes. Of course I am speaking about MLG Columbus. With many skeptics in the community, this was looked at with the worry of a parent’s eye wondering if things would work out between the two groups. While this is not an article about the event itself, this is about the stream and the casual experience for all video game enthusiasts.

For me, I have been one that has always wanted every community to work together. From my humble days a fan boy of Team Hate (bonus points if you remember them) to me running my own international events, I have enjoyed watching communities cross pollinate. MLG was no exception as the figurehead of competitive Halo and StarCraft entered the realm of the fighting game community. The stream, ran by community member Arturo “Sabin” Sanchez, merged the preconceived notion of #Esports with the community presentation that we all enjoy.

It began a bit slow due to the circumstances of one game King of Fighters 13. Compared to the other fighting games, KOF had only 25 entrants. The schedule was adjusted and unfortunately there was a bit of downtime. With not many matches to really broadcast, the event on stream was slow. This left commentators and stream producers with no other choice but to run several commercials at a time. Other technical hiccups occurred throughout the day. At times the stream would go down and other times people seemed uncomfortable on the microphone talking about the event. If anyone does not know why it’s simple…the staff was nervous.

Day two began a bit better. With the nerves gone, the event seemed a bit better managed. It started with Soul Calibur V and some great matches between players like Kayane, Keev, and RTD ATL. Thanks to the amazing commentary of Bibulus the hype and excitement of fighting games was in full effect. Later in the day we switched to 995Phil and the Mortal Kombat community with some more good matches. The day ended with the KOF finals where IGL Bala won collapsing after the victory overwhelmed with joy that he brought to himself, his country, and his family. I overall felt that there was so much riding on this day. With the world on their shoulders, the MLG staff came through and improved their event significantly. Fubarduck is the perfect straight man as commentary. At first glance he could seem “boring” with the way he speaks but put him together with someone that can get you excited he easily meshes well. While things ran a bit more smoothly, I think better communication between the staff running the event and the commentators overall would of made for better transitions. There were times where the commentators looked confused and did not set up the commercials properly. Also, commentators, especially with earpieces, should be told all details regarding schedule. They should be able to say something along the lines of “Up next, ___ vs. ____ next on MLG” without having to ask what is next.

For anyone that did not watch Day 3 here is a summary. Awesome! In Soul Calibur, Keev reminded everyone what country was the best in Soul Calibur capturing the title from RTD ATL. The commentary captured me thanks to Namco’s FlithieRich and Bibulus providing play-by-play. For someone who watches a lot of Capcom streams, I felt like this was one of the best teams in commentary. The ability to call the match and tell the story of the players captivated me to a point where I had my mouth gapped open hoping for the United States to win. This is what commentary should be doing. When we switched to Mortal Kombat, which is when the hype was raised even further. The first match we are given is the long-awaited VVV_CdJr vs. EMP Perfect Legend. 995 Phil does a masterful job of interviewing both players before the match. While the contestants seemed a bit out of place, 995Phil got them, and the crowd, pumped for the match. The fighting game community really had a treat watching this match. We saw two bitter rivals, two different outlooks on how they want to represent the community, and two overall good players battle it out. After the incredible match, whom VVV_CdJr had defeated, we had some of the most exciting matches in Mortal Kombat history. Let me not forget to mention the online warrior Curbulicious. From his first round lost, he put the pedal on as he cruised into an amazing 4th place finish taking out the likes of Tyrant and Perfect Legend. They put their hearts into those matches and it showed in the award ceremony. VVV_CdJr gave one of the most heartfelt thank you speeches I have ever seen. Not since the end of Apex 2010/Apex 2012 did I see so much emotion come from player. Sadly, for me, my connection had issues and I had to re-watch it a few minutes after it was done but emotions were running wild for him and his brothers.

I think that there were a few things Art and company can do to make the stream better. A lot of it really has to do with doing the events and gaining experience. This goes back to what I said previously about transitions to commercials, and interviews. Once they get that down it will be a better stream overall. I also think they can do a better job of setting up matches. The waits, while tolerable, were just a little longer than I expected them to be. I am sure, though, everyone will enjoy the next event and all the things I mentioned will be addressed.

One thing that this event has shown me, or revealed to me, is how much love these communities have for their games. To use Nor Cal Regionals as an example, I saw many people complain about the games they played. Whether win or lose twitter was expressing the sheer hatred people had for games such as Street Fighter, Marvel vs. Capcom, and Street Fighter x Tekken. It was a day that reminded me why I love gaming and also why I get upset at it as well. To see the differences in how people perceive both the Capcom and Non-Capcom games is unsettling. Yes I love all games but to see people still playing a game even though they hate it just does not make sense to me. At MLG we saw how much a tournament can be a greater experience. These people LOVED their games and you felt it in the commentary, the interviews, and the overall support they give each other. For me personally I became more inspired then I have ever been to make my own events reach this level. It is a reminder to everyone that there is nothing wrong with being different and playing the games you love whether they are popular or not.

MLG needs to make some improvements on their stream. There is not a single doubt about that. I would add though that the improvements will take time. Do not expect everything to be perfect on the first try. With determination Arturo and MLG made the event like a good tasting wine. The longer it was going the better it tasted. I am confident that next event will be even better. To those involved you did a great job and to those who went I hope you all enjoyed it.

Til next time

Layter Dayz

Who Am I? :

Pretty much I am a Tournament Organizer in the East Coast. I am really known in the Smash Community as the owner of Apex Series. We put on some big events xD. Overall I just want to be involved and help all the community, like the Smash community, that strive to get their time in the limelight.
 
Bibulus held it down very well, I feel he clicked more with MarkMan/FilthieRich than Fubarduck. Can't hate on the Fubar though, he prompted his co-commentator to explain system mechanics and the like where possible. I wish the Kayane vs. RTD match was streamed...and that the two international players weren't put in the same bracket, but all in all a strong weekend.
 
I dunno how this guy got this on the front page... But I can't say I disagree with much he said. Point me to said propaganda and I will remove the article. The main reason I'm not writing anything for the front page is it's supposed to be for news, and while I may write it as an unbiased entity it won't look like that. So I write nothing. If you have a legit beef with bullshit news content on the front page you let me know and I can see to it that it gets removed.

Oh and thanks for the compliments, I appreciate them very much.
 
Of course I am speaking about MLG Columbus. With many skeptics in the community, this was looked at with the worry of a parent’s eye wondering if things would work out between the two groups.

Implying that the skeptics are somehow unjustified in being skeptical.

The stream, ran by community member Arturo “Sabin” Sanchez, merged the preconceived notion of #Esports with the community presentation that we all enjoy.

It began a bit slow due to the circumstances of one game King of Fighters 13. Compared to the other fighting games, KOF had only 25 entrants. The schedule was adjusted and unfortunately there was a bit of downtime. With not many matches to really broadcast, the event on stream was slow. This left commentators and stream producers with no other choice but to run several commercials at a time. Other technical hiccups occurred throughout the day. At times the stream would go down and other times people seemed uncomfortable on the microphone talking about the event. If anyone does not know why it’s simple…the staff was nervous.

I.E. It's KoF's fault we as event staff aren't agile enough to adjust for circumstances.

The waits, while tolerable, were just a little longer than I expected them to be.

There were 5 matches in 2 hours.

To use Nor Cal Regionals as an example, I saw many people complain about the games they played.

Here we go with bashing the "competition" to mitigate the flaws of the event.

At MLG we saw how much a tournament can be a greater experience.

The context of this paragraph implies that NCR is not a good experience.

These people LOVED their games and you felt it in the commentary, the interviews, and the overall support they give each other. For me personally I became more inspired then I have ever been to make my own events reach this level. It is a reminder to everyone that there is nothing wrong with being different and playing the games you love whether they are popular or not.

This is an emotional appeal based on the above said implication.

Does that read enough like a flaw mitigation while subtly jabbing at the other tournament going on the same weekend in a fashion which makes them seem superior by some imagined standard of behavior (that is assumed superior) to anyone else?

This is shit. Get it off the front page. If you want to report on the tournament, do it, but if you want to be a shill for a position, don't do it under the guise of a tournament report.
 
I am not trying to do that.

Sorry if I was.

In all honesty I was trying to just provide a comparison to the things I saw on twitter and on the streams from both events.

Maybe my writing was off and for that I am really sorry. I, by no means, intentionally meant to disrespect anyone. I am only someone who has been around a long time in competitive gaming and just was providing a review of the stream.


TBH I should of introduced myself before I started the article. I will add that in.
 
I like your positive outlook Alex. And yes, with time MLG will get down a perfect formula for Fighters. As far as I know they're always open to criticsim.
 
I am ok with feedback. As a person getting back into writing I know I cannot get it right the first time. I will do my best to watch how I say things and make it better :)
 
Idle gives really good feedback sometimes, but he can also become really bitchy and bring nothing to the table, anyhow the stream was meh and there is room for improvement (lots)...the fights were awesome and the commentaries God like, I got hyped with a simple 2A cause of the way the said it.
 
So IIRC propaganda is using your pedestal as an authority to state misinformation as fact... I don't see that in what you pointed at.
 
I agree with a couple of things that IdleMind said. Alex if you wanted to speak on the MLG coumbus experience you should have left it at that. Instead you took subtle jabs at NCR at the beginning and middle of your post. Basically it looks like an advertisement for MLG, trying to point out why the other brand (NCR) is inferior. You wanna big up MLG? Fine, but don't put down other tourneys in the process. I was at NCR and the shit was great, and from what I hear the stream was a shitload better than the MLG stream.
 
Yea the title is a little misleading also. Its a review of the stream. If I do another review I'll definitely will take that into account. Overall I just used NCR , twitter, and other things as comparisons to what I felt was, despite some issues, a really good stream. The people that went to MLG can post up how they felt about the event. My perspective was from a purely spectating standpoint. Not as a stream monster per-se but someone who has worked in TV production and studied film. I am not saying I know everything...no one does...but I just wanted to review and compare.
 
what is with all the animosity here?

alex, nice write up. your opinions are as welcome as any others.

personally, i tried to watch the SC MLG stream. the matches were good, and the commentary was good, but the long commercial breaks and interview filler literally in between every single set...was intolerable. it was worse than trying to catch the last 15 minutes of an abused woman revenge drama on lifetime...commercial commercial commercial. even my friends that i had over to watch were disgusted by their length and frequency. i also was streaming it to a 52 inch TV, and wasn't allowed to do any acceptable stream resolution because i was not an MLG "member"? that is like requiring an email address to let me watch a program on NBC...i would just remove the channel from my browsing list. i wound up switching streams right before the grand finals because we just couldn't take it.

i was not at either event, and can't speak for them in and of themselves, but the NCR stream was around a million times better.

i hope you take this as constructive criticism. good luck on improving future events.
 
I just looked for him stating not fact as fact... It's not there. You want someone else to do that, talk to someone else. As you pointed out, my position looks like the perfect person to be biased. So I have to stick to facts and only facts. When you look at the stuff being said, it has a grounding in facts. You can't point to him stating something that isn't fact as fact and if you could I would take it down.

That and don't shoot the messenger I'm just the guy trying to address problems people have, because as much as I realize the position I'm in... Nobody else is there to do the job. Would you rather complain and have nobody respond?

Idle - I'm still waiting for you to point at some legit constructive criticisms on the event you called a total mess... Go for it, the more of those we get the better the next event will be.
 
Before we even get into talking about the event itself, there are a couple questions I really want to know the answers to.

Why is this on the front page?
What justification does this have existing on the front page?
Who decided it ought to go there?
Who is AlexStrife?

Back when Jaxel posted a couple of rather controversial articles, I felt it was understood that among the reasons it was upsetting was that it being on the front page made it seem as though it was representative of the majority- it wasn't. Hate Speech goes through great lengths to be a back and forth, and is conducted with a degree of class. What we have here is a second rate biased opinion piece that is pushing buttons. You know what that makes the site look like? A second rate site.
 
I didn't put it on the front page... I don't know exactly

lobo - I thought the interviews were good material. You get to make the event as much about the people playing as the games themselves. If I get more feedback like that I will kick it up the food chain.

The pacing on day 2 was ass, but finals day felt fine. There were a couple of delays that would have been nice to avoid... But you avoid someone getting so nervous they end up praying to the porcelain gods backstage. You really wanna DQ someone in top 5 because of that? Commercial bitching should be directed to Art @NYCFurby because his twitter is one of the main places we get feedback about that shit in particular.

Also the pacing of the day 2 stuff was tough to talk about fixing until sunday night. They have a schedule and matches run on it. So if you call a match early to go on stream, that isn't fair because of the strict DQ rules. If you call it late, it can work in certain circumstances so holding a match here or there to get more content on the stream is going to be done in the future. The main problem with Day 2 was they literally called the whole round of the tournament within 5 minutes of the start time and the next portion of the bracket isn't going on for half an hour. So there were a few times where it was a series per half hour... Which is something that needs much improvement and didn't look like a problem with KoF the night before. I had a nice long conversation with the TO after the event and Art + production staff in the post event wrap up... The short of it is, you will have more games next event.
 
Back
Top Bottom