Ban Hilde

Ban Hilde.


  • Total voters
    193
Status
Not open for further replies.

BanHilde

[08] Mercenary
Hilde, if not patched, will be the one character that will ruin the Soul Calibur community.

Now before you judge me as yet another whiner or make a vote on the poll, you should take a look at the California Regionals results and videos. Only once you've experienced Hilde will you understand her righteous fury.


The basic mechanics of the character are broken. If you whiff once, you either eat 100+ damage if your back is facing a wall, or you eat a ring out. Guaranteed. What other fighting game has something like this? Even in Tekken, getting punished means a large percentage of your life, but you can still come right back. With Hilde, however, one AND ONLY ONE mistake is all that is required for you to LOSE THE WHOLE ROUND.

If she is allowed to stay while unpatched, she will be the death knell to competitive play. She engenders a negative gameplay experience, especially for the one playing against her but even so for those just watching. Who would want to play this game after seeing something that they and even tournament pros would consider "bullshit"?


With the power of YouTube, word about Hilde will spread fast and far, so that's why I made this topic. As a community we have to come together on a consensus to nip this in the bud, lest it become SCIV's Variable Cancel. Everything else about the game is fun.

Except Hilde.

Ban Hilde.
 
Well, this ought to be good...

... or is going to lead to nowhere and everywhere at the same time.

One of the two.
 
BTW, who are you?

I am the combined voice of the Soul Calibur community; Those who have suffered under the terrible reign of Hilde and wish to see it end.

Who I am does not matter in the face of what I am. A messenger, with a message of hope that one day Hilde will be banned, and goodness and balance will once again shine upon our game.
 
Hilde, if not patched, will be the one character that will ruin the Soul Calibur community.

Hilde is the Magento of SCIV OMG'd

Ban Hilde.

Fixed...

In all seriousness, I don't think she's worth banning. Then again, I don't think any character in the game is worth banning.
 
Fixed...

In all seriousness, I don't think she's worth banning. Then again, I don't think any character in the game is worth banning.

Before you are tempted to vote no, I would suggest waiting for videos of the California Regional tournament, which I will link to here once they are available.


I too once thought that no character was worth banning, but when I finally saw her, my mind was instantly changed. I hope yours will be too once those videos are available.
 
Even though I voted yes, I do think that Hilde deserves special recognition for getting Vints to pay his bills.
 
To me, Hilde, Kilik, and Algol are about as deadly as one another.

Some say Yoda is anti-Hilde (but Yoda's banned... so he should be allowed if he's so useful). I don't know who anti-Kilik and anti-Algol are, but I'm sure there's something. So allow everything!
 
In before ban

Simone, this is a completely serious topic. Please don't joke about it.


You were right there in the front watching those Hilde matches and recording them. Did you think that was fun for everyone? I think their groans of "not this shit again" speaks volumes on how people will see this game if that is allowed.

Can you please give us an ETA of when the videos will be available? Also, thank you and Will so much for recording those vids.
 
"one AND ONLY ONE mistake is all that is required for you to LOSE THE WHOLE ROUND."

Uhm, on some stages that's also true with Kiliks FOTD.


I'm just sayin'...

PS, I love how the guy who got 2nd place at the cali regionals voted to ban hilde... that's gotta say something!
 
Because I main Astaroth, I don't have too much trouble with her. Her combos don't work right on Astaroth (and a few others if I'm not mistaken). That's not to say I like her or approve of her. However, I realize that if I mained someone that could get hit with the full combo, it would be a much harder fight, and I would hate her even more.
 
KDZ is playing Hilde now and he won a regional too. Why don't ya'll waste some time talking about that?
 
"one AND ONLY ONE mistake is all that is required for you to LOSE THE WHOLE ROUND."

Uhm, on some stages that's also true with Kiliks FOTD.

If you make one mistake close to the edge of the stage with anyone and your round is over too.. maybe we should ban ring outs and high dmg combos while we're at it.

I'm just sayin'...

There is a huge difference between mistakes near the edge, and mistakes from pretty much anywhere in the arena.


Also, I'll quote a reply I made in the Regionals thread that applies here:

If you can't defend against Hilde and you're not even going to try to figure out an anti-Hilde strat... then you shouldn't bother trying to be competitive.

If the anti-Hilde strat consists of never making a single mistake, when against a normal character you take damage but against Hilde you automatically lose the round, then NO ONE will bother trying to be competitive.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom