Actually no, asura does make kilik just that threatening. If he didnt have it there'd be way less to worry about when attacking. With X your right because she had a million different things that were way too good but no, not with kilik.
I don't think so. Kilik has a number of things you should worry about, not just Asura.
He was already a great character before this patch, and he'll continue to be a great character after it gets patched (assuming that it DOES get patched).
I think this move is pretty balanced as is. All you have to do is either block or sidestep, and you get a shitload of damage either way. The characters you play (Amy/X) rape this move HARD on block; they also get guaranteed auto GI for tons of damage. Hell, Amy's delayed BB/33B AND X's step B alone ensure that Kilik won't be Asura spamming them to death.
Cervy kills Asura.
Lizzy kills Asura.
HILDE kills Asura.
Amy/X kills Asura.
Cass/Sophie rapes Asura.
NM/Sieg kills Asura.
Asta ignores Asura.
Voldo kills Asura.
LET THE MAN HAVE ASURA FOR GOD'S SAKE! IT IS NOT AS OVERWHELMING AS YOU PEOPLE THINK IT IS!!!!
random note: KrayzieCD is the man :)