Well this is my first post on 8wayrun. The story is very scattered, with so many different endings. Even though the story up till now in SC4 does not make a lot of sense, there are ways to make this a more solid story line if there will be SC5. This is my take on what the story could be. It is a very long post. I am pretty much writing a plot for the character. So first I just establishing some themes, roles, settings ect. so that it make some sense. If the are any spelling/grammar mistake sorry, I hope it is not confusing.
Themesà there are many themes in the Soul Calibur, I think the most prevalent one are:
(I know all themes are “vs.” but after all this is a fighting game)
1)Good vs. Evil
Soul Calibur vs. Soul Edge
Good Guys vs. Bad Guys
Siegfried vs. Nightmare
Kilik/Xianghua vs. Soul Edge/Nightmare/Cervantes
Taki vs. Soul Edge/ Cervantes
2) Preordained Fate/Destiny vs. Controlling ones own Fate/Destiny
Ivy’s will vs. Her ties to Soul Edge
Zasalamel vs. His curse
Lizardman vs. His curse
Soul Edge purpose vs. Soul Edge’s will
3) Creator vs. Creation
Algol vs. Soul Edge
Zasalamel vs. Nightmare
Ivy vs. Soul Edge/Cervantes
4) Revenge/Vengeance vs Clemency/Grace/Justice
Maxi vs. Astaroth
Rock vs. Astaroth
Setsuka vs. Mitsurugi
Astaroth/Mitsurugi don’t respresent clemency, it is revenge vs. clemency from within Maxi, Rock, Setsuka
5) Desire for more Power vs. Power from Within
Yun-seong vs. Seong Mi-Na
Yun-seong vs. Talim
Raphael vs. Amy
6) Love vs. Duty
Sophitia’s love for her daughter vs. destroying Soul Edge
Cassandra’s love for her sister & family vs. destroying Soul Edge
Xianghua’s love for Kilik vs. destroying Soul Edge
Tira’s love for Nightmare vs. finding a suitable host
Voldo’s love for master vs. finding Soul Edge
Establishing Roles
The main player in the Soul Calibur Universe that really need to be involved in the finial showdown of Soul Edge and Soul Calibur:
Algol, Cassandra, Cervantes, Ivy, Kilik, Nightmare, Siegfried, Taki, Tira, Xianghua, Zasalamel, Edge Master, and Olcadan
Other characters that important to make the story flow and cover holes in the plot:
Amy, Hilde, Lizardman, Raphael, Seong Mi-Na, Sophitia, Talim, Yun-seong
Characters really affect Soul Edge vs. Soul Calibur story line:
Astaroth, Maxi, Mitsurgi, Rock, Setsuka, Voldo, Yoshimitsu
Soul Edge Current State
The pieces of Soul Edge is scattered at various places, I am assuming that now the remaining pieces of Soul Edge are at 8 places:
Algol—has pieces of Soul Edge in one of his arms(I think it left one)
Cervantes—has many pieces within this body
Ivy—her sword is a part of Soul Edge
Lizardman—some evil seed in his body, which turn him to a lizard (I think)
Nightmare—has soul edge
Rapheal—probably has pieces of Soul Edge with in him after the fight with Nightmare
Taki—one of her wepons has a piece of Soul Edge
Sophitia’s daughter
Setting
Most of the character will battle at the bottom of Algol’s castle/tower.
Algol is crystallize sitting in this thrown inside the tall castle/tower
Plot
These are just what I think should happen in SC5 and the plot is not very detailed. They are just the jist of what I think should happen.
Mini Plot-- Involving Maxi, Rock and Astaroth: Theme Vengeance/Justice
Maxi desires to kill once and for all Astaroth. When they meet and fight, Astaroth kills Maxi. After that Rock appears and also fight Astaroth. In their battle Rock kill Astaroth.
Reason I say Maxi should die is because his perspective is through revenge, and that became his down fall. Where as rock his perspective is through justice, know Astaroth would be a bigger threat if left alive.
Mini Plot-- Involving Setsuka and Mitsurugi
Setsuka feels or see some unnatural forces happening, I know Mitsurugi would be heading to that destination and she heads to that direction. She will come across Mitsurugi and face him in a duel. After a long battle they are extremely exhausted, and so they both prepare for a final strike. They both unleash their blades at each other; they stand across from each other face opposite direction. Mitsurugi smiles and falls to the ground dead. Setsuka then fall to her knees she is satisfied she has got her revenge, but she is wound severely and know she cannot be save, as she take her last breath she say “I will soon be with you” referring to her master.
Sub Plot-- Involving Seong Mi-Na, Talim, and Yun-seong: theme desire for power vs, power from within
Yun-seong diser Soul Edge and tries to obtain it by heading towards where the main battle is, Seong Mi-Na tries to stop him, but he defeats her but does not kill her. As he get closer to the main battle Talim intervenes and stop Yun-seong, she defeats him without killing him. She then say something rhetorical, and Yun-seong learns from his mistake.
Sub Plot-- Involving Rapheal, Amy, and Nightmare: Theme desire of power
Rapheal behave more and more aggressive, due to the Soul Edge pieces in him. It escalates to the point where he kills Amy, the one he wanted to protect by obtaining more power. In his weaken mental state, Nightmare come to get back the shards of Soul Edge, and kill Rapheal.
Reason is to enforce that power leads to destruction and loved one get hurt.
Sub Plot-- Involving Sophitia, Cassandra, and Kilik
Shophita’s daughter having the evil seed/Soul Edge in her becomes worse day by day. Eventually Kilik meets up with Sophitia and help her daughter using his artifacts to transfer evil seed/Soul Edge into him. As thanks Cassandra team up with Kilik on his quest to destroy Soul Edge
Sub Plot-- Involving Cassandra, Kilik, and Lizardman
On there journey they come across Lizardman. Cassandra fight him and defeats him but does kill. Kilik using his artifacts again transfers the evil seed/Soul Edge into him.
Main Plot-- Involves Siegfried, Hilde, Nightmare, Tira, Zasalamel
Nightmare in his quest to obtain all the pieces of Soul Edge to make the swords whole once more encounters Zasalamel. Zasalamel want to take Soul Edge from him to try and use it energies to lift this curse. So they battle Nightmare is the victor he then stabs Zasalamel and mocks him about wanting to die. Nightmare drain him of his power and soul and Zasalamel think to himself “think is not the death I long for”. His body become ash and differs in to the wind.
Meanwhile Siegfried and Hilde join forces to fight Nightmare. The two arrive at the bottom where Nightmare and Tira wait for them. The 4 do battle; with Siegfried wielding Soul Calibur strikes a heavy blow to Nightmare. Nightmare realizes that he will lose at this rate, grabs Tira by her throat and tell her you will be a part of me. Tira smile and starts to laugh, tells her self that she will never be alone. And with that, Nightmare absorbs her soul, and throws Tira’s lifeless corpse away. He continues the battle and is able to subdue and kill both Siegfried and Hilde.
Main Plot-- Cervantes, Nightmare Kilik, Xianghua, Cassandra
After nightmare defeated Siegfried and Hilde, Kilik, Xianghua, and Cassandra come to try and defeat Nightmare. Kilik alone fight Nightmare, and during the fight Xianghua see the sword Soul Calibur and take it. Kilik defeats Nightmare, as Nightmare tries to get back up, Cervantes shows up taking Soul Edge from Nightmare and Stabs him with his own sword. Nightmare power and body is absorbed into Soul Edge, the sword them merges with Cervanter’s weapon. He then quick strikes Kilik sensing that he has pieces of Soul Edge he absorbs the pieces from Kilik and is about to kill him, when Xianghua come to his aid with Soul Calibur. The two do battle, but Cervantes to strong for Xianghua, he knocks out Soul Calibur from her hand, then Cassandra come and uses her shield to defend Xianghua. She tells Xianghua to take Kilik and get out of here. Cassandra can do nothing but defend, her shield begin to crack.
Main Plot-- Cervantes, Cassandra, Taki, and Ivy
Cassandra feel she is done for but then she see a shadow pass in front of and then a loud not of sword clashing. The woman told her to get away, Cassandra got up and ran, and turn just to see who saved her. It was Taki, the same women who save her sister life, Cassandra and continued to run to help Kilik and Xianghua. Cervantes gleamed with a smile contemplating how he who shred this woman apart. As the though and struggled fighting with Taki, he felt another presents, it was his daughter, Ivy. Taki and Cervantes battle long and hard. During the battle Ivy spoted Soul Calibur and took it. The sword responds to her and took shape to her fighting style. As the fight continued Taki found an opening and strike Cervantes in the neck. She said it over for you, and Cervantes walked back little, covering his neck with his hand and was bit shaken. And said on contrary it over for you. He flew and stab Taki in the stomach. He said to her he was immortal and took her weapon that contains a piece of Soul Edge. Ivy came running to try and save Taki, Cervantes threw her body and said “I’ll deal with you later” he then ready himself for the next battle with his daughter. The father and daughter fought, but Ivy got the upper hand, and impaled Cervantes with Soul Calibur. Cervantes laughed saying her was immortal but as he finished this sentence this body soon turned to ash once again, the power of Soul Calibur made Cervantes killable. When his body became ash I got her soul back, and soon as she did she felt and burning sensation in the hand that held Soul Calibur. She dropped Soul Calibur.
Main Plot-- Invloving Ivy and Soul Edge
Then the pieces and energy of Soul Edge wrapped itself around Ivy and her weapon. Ivy became possessed; in her mind she was shackled and see and mirror image of herself glowing red that possessed her physical body. Soul Edge then smiled, and started to walk to up the tower, it only need one more peace to be complete.
Main Plot-- Edge Master, and Olcadan Kilik, Xianghua, Cassandra
As the 3 were walking away they were meet by Edge Master and Olcadan. (Out of ideas at this point)