so i found my match against Ramon with me playing a SC4 Hilde in SV5. If you watch the video, you'll notice that he gradually figures out how to beat her.
Other than that, critical edge is only practical in combos. It has slow start up and no invincibility/priority and horrible recovery.
Proof:
805, 911, 914, 1053 CE got stuffed by random moves
349 CE clashed by random move
515, 1057 CE slow recovery led to a punish
Charges lost all of their priority/tracking/recovery and you can just button mash to interrupt them:
801, 956, 714, 744
1047 c3b doesn't track at all
721 c2a hella punishable
Beginning of the end
836, 906, 1101, 1109
I couldn't seem to break throws while charging, so I don't know if that's possible anymore.
In SCIV, it was worth the risk to hinder yourself to have your fingers binded to buttons for charges for defense and 1 hit kills.
In this SCV, I can't say the same.